Psychic Healing – Miracle Cure or Dungeons & Dragons?
Imagine being treated for cancer, burns or high blood pressure without the aid of medication or surgery. Imagine already being cured of those maladies simply by someone willing you to be cured. Thats the assumption behind psychic healing, laying-on-of-hands, therapeutic touch and/or distant healing.
In my third novel, which is nevertheless in the idea stage, the psionic officer Doug possesses psychometabolic powers such as are described in D&Ds Complete Psionics Handbook (1), including healing, adrenalin control and cell adjustment, which method he could heal someones illness or wounds.
Does such a occurrence truly exist, opening the doors to miracles cures? Or is it nevertheless firmly confined to the vicinity of Dungeons and Dragons?
Research on the topic is staggering with nearly as many proponents for as there are debunkers against. already the Catholic Church has entered the fracas, taking a firm stance against Therapeutic Touch (2). In his paper to the Catholic Medical Association, P. Guinan states that therapeutic touch (quotations used by Guinan) is not a practice employed by the Catholic Hospital Pastoral Practice, after an extensive review of scientific literature.
While the term therapeutic touch is used interchangeably with laying-on-of-hands throughout his article, it appears that research in general has truly been splitting hairs and going in different directions, producing noticeable gaps between the various idioms.
An article in the prestigious Journal of the American Medical Association (3) reported that therapeutic touch (TT) claims are unfounded and that further use of TT by health professionals is unjustified. The authors state that TT was renamed as such because the original name, laying-on-of-hands, was considered inappropriate for modern society. consequently they limited their research to articles that included keywords such as TT or touch therapies.
However, a close inspection of the JAMA article discloses some interesting revelations. The initial point is that the first author listed under the title was a sixth-grade student at Loveland, Colorado at the time, and was only 9 years old when she completed her first trials. It was she who designed and conducted the tests cited in the article. The methods she developed were simplistic (i.e. which healing hand is closest to the subjects hand) in relation to the research conducted by advocates for psychic healing, who employed a variety of scientific techniques, such as electrocardiography (EKG), ultrasound (4) and already polygraphs (5).
The second notable aspect of the article is that nearly twenty percent of the references cited were doctoral dissertations or masters theses. As a Ph.D., I know first-hand the intense scrutiny a students research receives from the faculty group and the advising professor. I also am aware of the omnipresent politics and bureaucracy that a student must persevere and defer to during the journey and hopefully completion of graduate school.
The third and most interesting characterize is the absence of articles referencing names ubiquitous to psychic healing (as I have found in my research review), such as Oskar Estabany, Dr. Bernard Grad, William Braud and Marilyn Schlitz.
According to the web-site williamjames.com, in 1959 Dr. Bernard Grad conducted studies on Oskar Estabany, a former cavalry officer in the Hungarian army. Estabany was reported to have extraordinary healing powers, discovered while treating army horses. Dr. Grads research showed that mice who had a portion of skin removed were healed considerably faster by Mr. Estabanys treatment than the wounded mice who were not treated by him.
Further displays of the Hungarian healers abilities were studied by Smith (6), who discovered the healers ability to stimulate the activity of the enzyme trypsin as measured on a known substrate in vitro. Statistically meaningful stimulations of the enzyme activity were repeated consistently over a period of three weeks.
Dolores Krieger, who developed TT (and afterward trashed by the JAMA article) studied Estabany using hemoglobin levels as indicators of his talents (7). According to Varvoglis, Estabany applied his laying-on-of-hands (placing one or both hands on or near the patients body) to forty-nine people experiencing from a general range of unspecified illnesses. Hemoglobin levels of the treated group were statistically considerably higher and stayed elevated for a complete year than for an untreated group of twenty-nine patients with similar health problems.
Much of Dr. Grads research and articles with and without Mr. Estabany can be found listed by Dossey and Schwartz (8) and Ostrander and Schroeder (9).
W. Braud and M. Schlitz of the Mind Science Foundation in San Antonio, Texas are also discussed by M. Maher (4), James (5), Varvoglis (7) and Dossey and Schwartz (8), but not in the JAMA article as mentioned earlier nor in Guinans review. It is interesting that the nay-sayers go to great pains (or not-so-great) to debunk the psychic healing myth, stating that there is very little supporting it and however ignore important contributions to the study of the occurrence.
Braud and Schlitzs work on mental imagery is well-proven using a polygraph to record the electrodermal activity of the receiver or distant subject. The influencer or sender imagined the distant subject in appropriate relaxing or activating settings. Based on the results of thirteen experiments, the occurrence of this imagery is comparatively reliable and strong (5), which seems to sustain the aspect of telepathy instead of psychic healing. nevertheless, their research shows that intention alone can affect human physiology from a distance (4).
In their book Psychic Discoveries Behind the Iron Curtain, Ostrander and Schroeder (9) proven the abilities of Colonel Alexei Krivorotov, from the Georgian capitol of Tblisi, who worked in conjunction with his son, a medical doctor. The authors described how Col. Krivorotov moves his hands about five centimeters from a patients body. The patients reported feeling great heat from the colonels hands, although tests showed no change in temperature in neither Krivorotovs hands nor the patients skin. Ostrander and Schroeder, interestingly enough, leave the subject of the colonel at this point in the book without further discussing the final results of the patients he attempted to cure.
Maher et al (4) did extensive research on Healers and Patients in 1992, who were residents of St. Petersburg, Russia. The main focus of their research was on the tactile thresholds (sensitivity) of the fingers of Healers, Patients, Healer Simulators, and Patient Controls. Their results provided meaningful data that were consistent with the introspections of healers. They stated that the tests provide no more than a preliminary indication of the usefulness of this research and suggest refinements for future demanding tests such as using larger groups of subjects. In other words, they were not overwhelmed.
The famed Russian psychokinetic Ninel Kulagina (aka Neyla Mikhailova) reportedly could cause third degree burns on her stomach (9). This gives credibility to the idea that psychic powers can affect body tissue, in addition as enzymes. But was the stomach the only place Ms. Kulagina could produce these burns? Were burns the only injury she could produce?
So as the question was asked in my past article, Could Jean Grey Become Storm? (10), what is being affected here, or what course of action is the psychic healer using to cure? Medical doctors use thousands of surgical procedures and thousands of medicines to cure our ills, aches and pains. however very few, if any, of the healers mentioned here had any noted prior medical training. So if they do not know the intricacies and complexities of our bodies, how can they cure? Could the psychic healers be commanding our bodies own natural resources and defenses to cure us?
Looking at the research presented as a whole, it seems that our brain is the main thing that keeps us healthy and cures us. Whether it is psychic healing, the laying-on-of-hands, or therapeutic touch, maybe it is simply the closeness of a caring person that helps dissipate our anxieties and fears and allows our brain to relax and do its work, believing it will work. There appears to be a growing mistrust of the medical profession, either established or unfounded, and a move toward different treatments. As D. Kraig stated in Llewellyn Encyclopedia and Glossary (11), We are responsible for our own health.
1. S. Winter, The Complete Psionics Handbook, TSR, Inc. 1991.
2. P. Guinan, Therapeutic Touch is not a Catholic Hospital Pastoral Practice Linacre Quarterly, February 2004, pp 5-14.
3. L. Rosa, E. Rosa, L. Sarner, S. Barrett, A Close Look at Therapeutic Touch. The Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 279, No. 13, April 1, 1999, pp 1005-1010.
4. M. Maher, I. Vartanian, T. Chernigovskaya, R. Reinsel, Physiological Concomitants of the Laying-on-of-Hands: Changes in Healers and Patients Tactile Sensitivity. Parapsychology Association, 1992.
5. W. James, Psionics – functional Application of Psychic Awareness. http://www.williamjames.com/Science/PSIONIC2.htm.
6. T. Bunnell, The Effect of Healing with Intent on Pepsin Enzyme Activity. J Scientific Exploration, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 139-148, 1999.
7. M. Varvoglis, Psychic (Distant) Healing. Parapsychology Association, June 7, 2000.
8. L. Dossey, S. Schwartz, Therapeutic Intent/Healing Bibliography of Research. http://www.stephanaschwartz.com/distant_healing_biblio.htm.
9. S. Ostrander, L. Schroeder, Psychic Discoveries Behind the Iron Curtain, Prentice-Hall, Inc., NJ, 1970.
10. A. Scott, Could Jean Grey Become Storm?, EzineArticles.com; Published 9/04/2007
11. D. Kraig, Psychic Healing. http://www.llewellynencyclopedia.com